Vikings QB McCarthy needs surgery on meniscus tear in right knee, a big setback in rookie’s progress

Minnesota Vikings quarterback J.J. McCarthy faces an uncertain future after being diagnosed with a torn meniscus in his right knee, which will require surgery. This injury is a significant setback for the rookie, who had been making promising strides during the preseason.

Coach Kevin O’Connell revealed the diagnosis on Tuesday. McCarthy sustained the injury during his exhibition game debut on Saturday, where he completed 11 of 17 passes for 188 yards, including two touchdowns and one interception against the Las Vegas Raiders. The rookie reported ongoing knee pain when the team regrouped on Monday, prompting further medical evaluations.

The Vikings have yet to schedule McCarthy’s surgery or determine the exact length of his recovery. Depending on the severity of the tear, he might return within a month, but there is also a possibility he could miss the entire season. The rehabilitation timeline will vary based on whether the tear requires a full repair or just a minor trim, with the exact details becoming clear only after the surgery.

This injury comes as a considerable disappointment given McCarthy’s potential and the team’s plans to increase his participation with the first-team offense during the remaining days of training camp. Despite the setback, McCarthy attempted to lift team spirits with an optimistic social media update.

Meanwhile, the Vikings are traveling on Tuesday for joint practices and a preseason game against the Cleveland Browns. With McCarthy sidelined, Sam Darnold, who has been the top quarterback throughout the spring and summer, will be confirmed as the starter for the season. Nick Mullens will step in as the primary backup, and Jaren Hall will continue in his second year on the roster. Coach O’Connell mentioned that the team currently has no plans to sign another quarterback.